Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense

"Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense" as motto

This motto, often in the 19th century by charitable organizations and theatrical and other cultural companies, is derived from an Anglo-Norman maxim which apparently originally meant something like "Shame on whomsoever would think badly of it" in Old French, though at times re-interpreted to mean "Evil to him who evil thinks".[1] It is most famous for its use as the motto of the British chivalric Order of the Garter[2].

Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense as the name of a theatre company

The motto on a number of occasions served - formally and informally as the name of certain companies. (In some instances even shortened to "Honi" in adverts, reviews and other publications.)

Villet's company

The motto was first utilized in Cape Town by the first French-Dutch players in the Cape, best known as Het Fransche Liefhebbery Geselschap (or the French Amateur Company in English), founded by Charles Mathurin Villet. They clearly have the orginal meaning in mind, for the motto is given in the full phrase Consacre a la Bienfaisance, Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense (= "Dedicated to charity, Evil to him who thinks ill of it"). However the company never used the motto as the name for their company.

When C.E. Boniface became involved with the French Theatre Company in the period 1807-9, he apparently also used the motto and perhaps even used it as an informal name for the company as well.

See also Het Fransche Liefhebbery Geselschap

The Multilingual company

With the collapse of the French Theatre Company and the founding of the Dutch Company Tot Nut en Vermaak , the shortened version of the motto, Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense, formally became the name of a bilingual (perhaps even trilingual) company. The company was initially referred to as " Het Afrikaansche Liefhebbery Gezelschap" ("the African Amateur Company") with its first production, that of C.E. Boniface's ballet pantomime Het Beleg van Troyen in 1813, but assumed its motto as name in 1814, when it was first used in the advertisment for the Boniface's next ballet, Sappho, to open on July 4, 1815. It was an extremely disciplined and influential multilingual company, managed by Boniface, which performed in Dutch, French, English, or a combination thereof. It appears to have been without competition in 1814-1816, but was then overshadowed by Tot Nut en Vermaak, especially during 1817-18, and in 1819, as English theatre became strong again, it became part of [[Men Doet Wat Men Kan.

Among its other productions in this period include:

In 1815: De Lauwerkrans, of Het Gezag der Wetten (Ziegler), De Belachelyke Zelfmoord (Martainville), Eerzucht en Behoefte, of De Huwelyksscheiding uit Liefde (Patrat), De Wanhoop van Jocrisse (Dorvigny), De Struikroovers van Kalabrien, of De Onveilige Wildernis (Tréogate), Jocrisse in Eenen Nieuwen Dienst (Dorvigny), Jean-Pierre-Diogenes, of L'Orateur dans un Tonneau and Men Doet Wat Men Kan, Niet Wat Men Wil (Dorvigny).

Boniface's company

In 1823 they performed as "Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense" again, now with C.E. Boniface as formal manager. Also later referred to as Het Zuid-Afrikaansche Tooneel Gezelschap or The South African Amateurs in most adverts. "Honi" became Door Yver Bloeit de Kunst in 1833 and eventually Vlyt en Kunst in 1834-1837. All in all had an enormous impact on the development of Boniface's art and on the Afrikaans theatre in particular.

The company members

According to W.G. Groom (quoted by F.C.L. Bosman, 1928, p 372) the key members of the company - besides C.E. Boniface himself - included Jannie Overbeek, Michael Wolff, Jan Smalberg, P. Auret, L.P. Biel, G. Martin, Miss Roselt, Miss de Necker, possibly L.H. Meurant. From handbills can be added the names of B. van de Sandt, D. Disant, H. Roselt, W. Brandt, F. Waldek, De la Sablonière, A. de Waal, W. Burnet, R.S. Allemann, De la Colline, J. Terhoven, A. de Kock, J. de Kock, K. de Kock, J. Herholdt, C. Brink, Mr Munnik, J.J. Piton, and Miss L.E. Meurant. In addition there were many dancers who performed for his company.

Plays produced

In 1923: Het Geweten (Iffland) , De Keukenhelden, Verzoening en Rust (Von Soden), De Belachelyke Zelfmoord (Martainville), Rinaldo Rinaldini (Vulpius), Celina, of Het Kind des Geheims (Pixérécourt), De Dolzinnige, of De Gewaande Dolleman (Boniface) , and Komplimenten en Wind (Bretzner)

In 1924: Kabaal en Liefde (Schiller), De Verwarde Schaking (Von Kotzebue), Les Deux Chasseurs et La Laitière (Anseaume), Hugo de Groot (Von Kotzebue), De Dronkaart (Von Kotzebue).

In 1925: De Burger Edelman (Molière/Boniface) on 28 May 1825

De Vrouw met Twee Mannen (Pixérecourt) and The Liar (Foote) on 15 October 1825.

The theatre company Honi Soit qui Mal y Pense in Grahamstown

Grahamstown had a Theatrical Amateur Society [sic], or Grahamstown Amateur Company which used the same motto in the years 1837-1839.

According to Laidler (Annals, p. 40, cited in F.C.L. Bosman, 1928: pp. 388-390) they apparently produced the following plays:

In 1837: The Rivals (Sheridan) and Bombastes Furioso (Rhodes);

In 1838: The Castle Spectre, or The Ghost of Evelina (Lewis); The Rivals (Sheridan); Bombastes Furioso; Chrononhotonthologos (Carey); The Spectre Bridegroom (Moncrieffe); The Midnight Hour (Inchbald); Love Laughs at Locksmiths (Colman Jr); Fortune's Frolic and (possibly - though Bosman disputes this) the song Kaatje Kekkelbek. (However, there is some difference of opinion Bosman and Laidler on whether the works listed by Laidler for 1938 were performances done in Cape Town - as claimed by Laidler- or that at least some of them were actually performed in Grahamstown - as argued by Bosman).

In 1839: The Innkeeper of Abbeville (Fitzball); Love, Law and Physic (Kenney)

Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honi_soit_qui_mal_y_pense

F.C.L. Bosman, 1928. Drama en Toneel in Suid-Afrika, Deel I: 1652-1855. Pretoria: J.H. de Bussy. [3]: pp. 79, 118, 122, 134-141, 161, 165, 174, 178, 209, 233, 256, 274-299, 341, 359, 360, 363, 366, 369, 372-379, 388-9.

F.C.L. Bosman, 1980

Jill Fletcher, 1994;

P.W. Laidler, 1926;

P.J. du Toit, 1988

[TH, JH]

Go to the ESAT Bibliography

Return to

Return to South African Theatre Venues, Companies, Societies, etc

Return to PLAYS I: Original SA plays

Return to PLAYS II: Foreign plays

Return to PLAYS III: Collections

Return to PLAYS IV: Pageants and public performances

Return to South African Festivals and Competitions

Return to The ESAT Entries

Return to Main Page